Rankin appointment fires up the muck-rakers

Alf would rather see more media focus on the need for a Family Commission than the rationale behind the appointment of Christine Rankin as a commissioner.

They should examine its purpose, its resources, its costs, its accomplishments, and so on, so we would be better able to judge what sorts of people would make good commissioners.

His thinking is reinforced by the Sunday tabloids’ delving into the suicide of the late Margo McAuley, whose widower, Kim MacIntyre, became Rankin’s fourth husband.

The Sunday News brays:

Today Sunday News can reveal the mother-of-two hired by the National administration to bring families closer together has been accused of being instrumental in the demise of a marriage of around one year, which ended last year with the lonely death of a prominent real estate agent.

The Sunday News goes on to salivate:

One month after McAuley died, Rankin and MacIntyre were videoed dancing together on election night at the National Party’s celebrations at Auckland’s Sky City Grand Hotel.

They now live together on Auckland’s North Shore.

Wellington businessman Kris Gallagher married to McAuley before MacIntyre told Sunday News his ex-wife had displayed symptoms of depression during their seven-year marriage but the condition appeared to him to worsen when she learned of MacIntyre’s affection for Rankin

The Herald on Sunday has a similar story:

New Families Commissioner Christine Rankin is facing fresh criticism after revelations she married a Wellington man just months after his previous wife took her own life.

Close friends and colleagues of Margo McAuley, 42, who died last October, say they are appalled at the circumstances of Rankin’s recent, fourth marriage and her Cabinet appointment to the Families Commission.

“Revelations” is bullshit.

According to the newspaper’s report, Social Development Minister Paula Bennett knew about the suicide when she made the appointment:

The Herald on Sunday has learned that Social Welfare Minister Paula Bennett was told about McAuley’s death before the decision to appoint Rankin. Bennett refuses to comment.


It is understood Government ministers were aware of issues related to McAuley’s death and it is believed this is what prompted a heated discussion at Cabinet last Monday after Rankin’s appointment was revealed.

In short, the Herald (like the Sunday News) saw the Rankin appointment as a pretext for regurgitating domestic stuff about the threesome involved and revisiting Margo McAuley’s death.

McAuley, one of New Zealand’s top-performing real estate agents, took her own life on October 29.
She was married to Kim MacIntyre, who married Rankin less than six months after his wife’s funeral.

“The simple answer to this Christine Rankin situation is surely, surely the judgment shown has been appalling, hasn’t it?” said McAuley’s former boss, Tommy Hepinstall of Wellington firm Tommy’s Real Estate.

“If I died tomorrow I would hope my wife would remarry but for someone to marry someone after such a horrific death that Margo had, in such a short period of time… you have to wonder.

“Surely, surely anyone with a little bit of compassion for family, for work colleagues for anybody – I cannot believe that someone who is going to be [a senior member] of a thing called the Families Commission could make such a poor judgment call on families.”

So what exactly is a decent time before the couple could have married in these circumstances?

And would that have made the appointment any more acceptable?

Another close friend of McAuley believes her friend was battling many issues in her life, including some in her relationship.

The woman said she had received a text from McAuley 12 days before her death, which said: “I am struggling at the moment, Kim has told me he is thinking of leaving. He is going away for Labour Weekend to make his final decision so I am a bit shattered at the mo.”

She said McAuley’s family – she was one of 10 siblings but had no children of her own – had been distressed and angry after her death.

The woman questioned Rankin’s appointment.

“How could someone so insensitive be appointed to such a sensitive position? It makes a mockery of the Families Commission and to all those who love Margo.”

She said McAuley, MacIntyre and Rankin had all become friends – it is understood McAuley met Rankin when she was selling her house.

“I knew Kim because he was a friend, too, of course,” said the woman. “I feel very strange now especially when I see them together and they start holding hands – it’s weird.”

So the couple hold hands.

Obviously they are happy together.

That’s nobody’s business but theirs.

Revenue Minister Peter Dunne told the Herald on Sunday he had opposed Rankin’s appointment since he was first told it was a possibility in March, and before even considering the McAuley situation, “there were many other obvious reasons why Rankin was unsuitable to be a Families Commissioner.”

So why hasn’t the Sunday press explored these?

The answer is that it’s much, much easier to whet a public appetite for suicide and gossip than to thoroughlky examine all the factors behind Rankin’s fitness or otherwise to hold office – or whether there should be an office for her and the other commissioners to fill.

3 Responses to Rankin appointment fires up the muck-rakers

  1. […] Busted Blonde, at Roarprawn, apparently got up a bit later than Alf to buy her Sunday newspapers, only to find them pathetically preoccupied with suicide and gossip. […]

  2. Karin Berryman says:

    The Pot Calling The Kettle Black

    Christine Rankin’s actions and what she said on ‘Sunday’ (which screened on TV on Sunday 17 May 2009) referring to Margo McCauley is nothing less than abhorrent. i.e.: “…a complex friend..at times a difficult friend…but still a friend…” If you can’t say something nice… and “…there was NO affair” NO A F F A I R ?? Eh???!!

    Ofcourse there must have been an “affair” – even if had been a “courtship” – that would still equate to having an affair! If Christine Rankin did not have an affair with Kim MacIntyre then what did she have??? Just an agreement that one day they will marry and live happily ever after?? – yeah, right!!! And according to the Sunday programme, Christine married Kim less than 6 months following Margo’s death – NOT..less than 4 months more like.

    As for becoming the Families Commissioner …well, talk about ‘The Pot Calling The Kettle Black’ !!! – afterall, this whole ‘affair’ (excuse the pun) involved much more than just Margo, Kim (her late husband) and his bit of fluff (Christine Rankin)! It has deeply affected Margo’s entire family in Ireland, and let us not forget, Margo’s step-children – her family, Margo’s FAMILY! (Kim’s children).

    I used to have such admiration for Ms Rankin…that is up until I heard the shocking news about her and Kim MacIntyre. I put her on a pedestal and believed that she would be a wonderful ambassador as Families Commissioner – speaking out and without doubt commanding attention on this very sensitive and emotive issue… and being heard! She has a voice (there’s no doubt about that!) and she would have been heard…just as she was on the Sunday programme that screened on Sunday evening – 17 May 09.

    As Families Commissioner, it is not just about speaking out for babies thrown in tumble dryers and hung from close-lines but about F A M I L I E S! ENTIRE families. THE FAMILY U N I T !!

  3. Mary Browne says:

    How could someone claim to represent “The Family” and be out dancing with the husband of a lady who died tragically, on the very day that that man’s wife was being buried in Ireland, 9th november 2008. No affair ! !

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: